WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine with S4 Monitor
WaterRower's handcrafted ash wood rower uses a water tank for resistance, producing the most authentic on-water rowing feel of any home machine with a sound level and aesthetic that suits living spaces.
- Water tank resistance produces a smooth, natural catch and drive feel that matches open-water rowing
- Handcrafted ash wood construction stores vertically when not in use, functioning as furniture
- Quieter than air resistance machines; the water sound is ambient rather than fan-driven
Best For / Not For
Best for
- Buyers who want the most authentic rowing feel and are willing to pay the premium for water resistance
- Home gym or living room installations where gym equipment aesthetic is a problem
Not for
- Buyers who need the Concept2 PM5's performance tracking for competitive or structured training
- Buyers optimizing for the lowest cost per quality workout
Key Details
Water Resistance vs. Air Resistance: The Feel Difference
Water resistance creates drag by spinning a paddle in a water tank. The resistance increases as the paddle spins faster, which happens when you pull harder. This produces a natural acceleration curve through the drive phase that closely matches actual rowing on water. Air resistance works similarly but through a fan flywheel, producing a slightly different drag curve. Experienced rowers describe water resistance as marginally more fluid; non-rowers rarely notice the difference.
The WaterRower's vertical storage is a meaningful practical advantage in living spaces. The machine stands upright against a wall in a footprint smaller than a bookshelf. In a home gym that doubles as a bedroom or living room, the ability to store equipment vertically and out of walking paths is not a minor detail.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Water resistance provides the most authentic catch-and-drive feel of any home machine
- Ash wood construction and vertical storage make it acceptable as living room furniture
- Quieter ambient sound compared to the fan noise of air resistance machines
Cons
- S4 monitor does not measure watts, limiting structured power-based training
- Premium price over magnetic resistance machines with equivalent health benefits
Bottom Line
Buy the WaterRower Natural if you want the most authentic rowing feel, a premium aesthetic that works in a home setting, and quiet water resistance. Choose the Concept2 if performance tracking and PM5 accuracy are higher priorities than aesthetics.
Check current price on Amazon
