As an Amazon Associate, RateLab earns from qualifying purchases.

RateLab Kitchen & Dining Toasters

Best Toasters

Updated

We reviewed pop-up toasters across browning controls, slot width, build materials, and daily usability. Every toaster in this review handles thick-cut bread and bagels and has a removable crumb tray. Toaster ovens are a separate category -- these are dedicated two-slot and four-slot pop-up toasters.

The most underrated toaster spec is slot width. Standard 1.25-inch slots work for commercial sandwich bread but jam on artisan bakery slices, homemade bread, and most bagels. Extra-wide slots at 1.5 inches or wider handle everything without forcing or damaging your bread. If you buy a lot of thick-cut or artisan bread, extra-wide slots are the first thing to check.

Browning evenness matters more than browning speed. A toaster that produces golden on one side and pale on the other is consistently frustrating, regardless of how many shade settings it has. Review analysis consistently shows that toasters with quartz or nichrome heating elements and wider slot spacing outperform budget models on this dimension. The Lift & Look feature on premium models -- which lets you check progress mid-cycle without restarting -- is one of those small features that becomes something you miss on every other appliance.

Quick picks

Use this table for the fastest answer, or jump into the full review cards below.

Pick Best for Verdict Review
Best OverallBreville BTA820XL Buyers who want a premium toaster that genuinely lasts for years, Anyone who toasts artisan bread, homemade loaves, or thick-cut slices regularly Buy Read review
Best Budget PickCuisinart CPT-122 Budget buyers who need a reliable daily toaster without premium pricing, Small kitchens and apartments where counter space is limited Buy Read review
Best 4-SliceHamilton Beach 4-Slice Families who need to toast 4 slices simultaneously on school mornings, Households that eat Texas toast, frozen waffles, or thick-cut bread regularly Buy Read review
Best DesignKitchenAid KMT2116 Buyers who want to color-match their toaster to an existing KitchenAid stand mixer, Anyone who frequently toasts English muffins or small items that need a high-lift lever Buy Read review
Best Retro DesignSmeg TSF01 Buyers building a coordinated Smeg kitchen ecosystem with matching small appliances, Design-first kitchens where the aesthetic is the primary purchase driver Consider Read review

Best Toasters

Best Overall

Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster, 2 Slice, Brushed Stainless Steel

The Breville BTA820XL is the gold standard for pop-up toasters. Die-cast metal housing that feels built to last a decade. The Lift & Look feature lets you check browning mid-cycle without restarting. A Bit More adds a few seconds when the toast isn't quite there. Extra-wide slots handle artisan bread, thick-cut slices, and full-size bagels without forcing. Bagel and defrost functions are standard. Backed by strong buyer feedback, this is the toaster serious home cooks buy and keep for years.

Buy
TL;DR

Strong feedback from verified Amazon buyers

Pros

  • Die-cast housing is meaningfully more durable than plastic alternatives
  • Lift & Look is the single most useful toaster feature not found on budget models
  • A Bit More eliminates the frustration of underdone toast without a full restart
  • Extra-wide slots handle every bread type without issue
  • The strongest buyer feedback in this category

Cons

  • Premium price point -- 3-4x the cost of a basic Cuisinart
  • Only 2-slice capacity -- households that need 4 slices need a different model
  • Single browning dial controls both slots -- no independent left/right settings
Verdict: Buy Full Review Check current price

Best Toasters

Best Budget Pick

Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, 7 Shade Settings

The Cuisinart CPT-122 is the default answer for buyers who want a reliable toaster without spending real money. Strong feedback from a large number of buyers across years of production. Extra-wide slots at 1.5 inches handle bagels and thick slices. Seven shade settings, a high-lift carriage, and dedicated reheat, defrost, and bagel buttons. Compact footprint fits sideways in tight counter setups. Backed by Cuisinart's three-year warranty. Not glamorous, but consistently good.

Buy
TL;DR

Strong feedback from a large number of verified Amazon buyers

Pros

  • Strong feedback from one of the largest buyer bases in this category
  • Compact footprint makes it the practical choice for tight counter setups
  • Extra-wide slots handle bagels without the narrow-slot frustration
  • Three-year warranty is meaningful for a budget appliance
  • Cuisinart brand reliability comes with customer service backing

Cons

  • Plastic housing runs slightly warm on the outside during heavy use
  • Basic styling with no color options beyond standard
  • No Lift & Look or premium features found on the Breville
Verdict: Buy Full Review Check current price

Best Toasters

Best 4-Slice

Hamilton Beach 24798 4 Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots and Sure-Toast Technology

The Hamilton Beach 24798 uses Sure-Toast technology that keeps all four slots browning evenly -- even when only one or two slots are in use. Extra-wide slots handle Texas toast, frozen waffles, and full bagels without jamming. Two slide-out crumb trays make cleanup genuinely easy, not an afterthought. Backed by strong feedback from a large number of verified buyers, this is the validated standard for 4-slice toasters. Nothing else at this price point competes on capacity and performance.

Buy
TL;DR

Strong feedback from a large number of verified Amazon buyers

Pros

  • Strong feedback from the largest buyer base of the 4-slice toasters here
  • Sure-Toast technology solves the uneven browning problem endemic to cheap 4-slot designs
  • Two crumb trays for two independent slot groups makes cleanup twice as fast
  • Extra-wide slots handle the full range of bread types without modification
  • Competitive pricing for 4-slice capacity

Cons

  • Larger counter footprint than 2-slice alternatives
  • Plastic accents on the body -- not the most premium look
  • No digital display or countdown indicator
Verdict: Buy Full Review Check current price

Best Toasters

Best Design

KitchenAid KMT2116 2 Slice Slot Toaster with High Lift Lever

The KitchenAid KMT2116 is the toaster you buy when the counter look matters. Available in Empire Red, Onyx Black, Contour Silver, and several other finishes, it matches the KitchenAid stand mixer palette exactly. Functionally, the high-lift lever is the standout feature -- it boosts small items up high so you can grab English muffins without burning fingers. Keep Warm holds toast at temperature for up to three minutes when breakfast gets chaotic. Seven browning settings round it out.

Buy
TL;DR

Strong feedback from a smaller pool of verified Amazon buyers

Pros

  • Color matching across the KitchenAid lineup makes coordinated kitchen setups genuinely achievable
  • High-lift lever is a daily convenience feature that prevents burned fingers on English muffins
  • Keep Warm is a practical function for households where toast and eggs don't always finish simultaneously
  • 7 browning settings
  • Solid metal housing matches the premium feel of the color finish

Cons

  • Check the cord length against your counter layout before ordering
  • Mid-range price without the premium features of the Breville
Verdict: Buy Full Review Check current price

Best Toasters

Best Retro Design

SMEG TSF01 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function, Stainless Steel

The Smeg TSF01 is the toaster you buy when the kitchen is the showpiece and the budget is secondary. Italian retro design in pastel colors and stainless steel that looks like it arrived from 1950s Milan. Six presets, defrost, and a removable crumb tray are functional. Where it earns a consider rather than a buy is the price -- at a premium price, it performs essentially the same function as the Cuisinart. The Smeg premium is almost entirely aesthetic. If you are building a Smeg kitchen ecosystem, it belongs. If you are not, it doesn't.

Consider
TL;DR

Italian retro design in multiple pastel and stainless finishes

Pros

  • Italian retro design is genuinely beautiful and unlike anything else in the category
  • Smeg ecosystem compatibility means one unified aesthetic across multiple appliances
  • Stainless steel housing is premium and durable
  • 6 preset browning settings with consistent results
  • Available in a wider color range than KitchenAid or Breville

Cons

  • Premium price for essentially the same function as a budget toaster
  • No standout functional features like Lift & Look (Breville) or Sure-Toast (Hamilton Beach)
  • If you are not buying into the Smeg ecosystem, the premium is hard to justify on function alone
Verdict: Consider Full Review Check current price

All Toasters reviews

The grid is generated from product data and is ready to paginate once the subcategory passes 20 products.

Kitchen / Toasters Buy

Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster, 2 Slice, Brushed Stainless Steel

The Breville BTA820XL is the gold standard for pop-up toasters. Die-cast metal housing that feels built to last a decade. The Lift & Look feature lets you check browning mid-cycle without restarting. A Bit More adds a few seconds when the toast isn't quite there. Extra-wide slots handle artisan bread, thick-cut slices, and full-size bagels without forcing. Bagel and defrost functions are standard. Backed by strong buyer feedback, this is the toaster serious home cooks buy and keep for years.

Read review →
Kitchen / Toasters Buy

Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, 7 Shade Settings

The Cuisinart CPT-122 is the default answer for buyers who want a reliable toaster without spending real money. Strong feedback from a large number of buyers across years of production. Extra-wide slots at 1.5 inches handle bagels and thick slices. Seven shade settings, a high-lift carriage, and dedicated reheat, defrost, and bagel buttons. Compact footprint fits sideways in tight counter setups. Backed by Cuisinart's three-year warranty. Not glamorous, but consistently good.

Read review →
Kitchen / Toasters Buy

Hamilton Beach 24798 4 Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots and Sure-Toast Technology

The Hamilton Beach 24798 uses Sure-Toast technology that keeps all four slots browning evenly -- even when only one or two slots are in use. Extra-wide slots handle Texas toast, frozen waffles, and full bagels without jamming. Two slide-out crumb trays make cleanup genuinely easy, not an afterthought. Backed by strong feedback from a large number of verified buyers, this is the validated standard for 4-slice toasters. Nothing else at this price point competes on capacity and performance.

Read review →
Kitchen / Toasters Buy

KitchenAid KMT2116 2 Slice Slot Toaster with High Lift Lever

The KitchenAid KMT2116 is the toaster you buy when the counter look matters. Available in Empire Red, Onyx Black, Contour Silver, and several other finishes, it matches the KitchenAid stand mixer palette exactly. Functionally, the high-lift lever is the standout feature -- it boosts small items up high so you can grab English muffins without burning fingers. Keep Warm holds toast at temperature for up to three minutes when breakfast gets chaotic. Seven browning settings round it out.

Read review →
Kitchen / Toasters Consider

SMEG TSF01 2 Slice Toaster with 6 Presets and Defrost Function, Stainless Steel

The Smeg TSF01 is the toaster you buy when the kitchen is the showpiece and the budget is secondary. Italian retro design in pastel colors and stainless steel that looks like it arrived from 1950s Milan. Six presets, defrost, and a removable crumb tray are functional. Where it earns a consider rather than a buy is the price -- at a premium price, it performs essentially the same function as the Cuisinart. The Smeg premium is almost entirely aesthetic. If you are building a Smeg kitchen ecosystem, it belongs. If you are not, it doesn't.

Read review →

Related Categories

Keep comparing nearby buying guides before you choose.

Kitchen & Dining

Kitchen Sponges

Kitchen sponges ranked by cleaning power, durability, scratch resistance, and real-world value.

View rankings →
Kitchen & Dining

Air Fryers

Air fryers ranked by crispiness, capacity, ease of cleaning, and real household value.

View rankings →
Kitchen & Dining

Coffee Makers

Coffee makers ranked by brew quality, ease of use, reliability, and value across drip, pod, and espresso styles.

View rankings →
Kitchen & Dining

Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron cookware ranked by seasoning quality, heat retention, weight, versatility, and long-term durability.

View rankings →